When I was in high school, my parents and pastors taught me several things about other religions. One of the things they told me was that it's considered a moral imperative in Islam to lie to Christians. This 'fact' was then used as a method of denying any claim a Muslim made to the contrary - of course Muslims would say that their Qur'an says nothing of the sort, because they're supposed to lie!
I still see this today. It's a belief about Islam that has persisted despite all of the world's attempts to answer it. Just in a brief search online, I found many sites making claims that support that belief:
On a site with an Orwellian name, MuslimFact.com, Don Boys argues that "Islam permits lying to deceive unbelievers and bring world domination," explaining that this right to lie is called "Al-taqiyya" and that it can be used in several fairly common-place scenarios, such as saving someone's life.
This is somewhat true, actually. The Qur'an appears to be saying - although I'm no scholar of the Qur'an and do not speak Arabic to read it untranslated - that Muslims shouldn't lie in general but can do so in order to accomplish good things, such as saving lives and reconciling people together. Boys acknowledges that Christians lie, too, but then brushes that under the rug by the argument that we're not given specific permission to lie, and will therefore feel guilt for it. That's clearly working out for the vast majority of Christians.
He then follows a slippery slope argument down to its most absurd conclusion, setting it up as follows:
"Muslims have no hope for eternal salvation without their good works, so
they must keep working to advance Islam. If a few lies will accomplish
that goal, then lying is not bad but good. If they can get good
publicity for Islam by lying, then lying is acceptable, even desirable.
The Muslim is earning his way to heaven by lying to a non-Muslim."
Wow... where to begin? First, this assumes (and Boys acknowledges the assumption without apparently realizing what he's saying) that Muslims don't have Christ and therefore their salvation isn't guaranteed. Well, that's true, except that as Beth Davies-Stofka on patheos.com explains, "Islam does not teach that humans need intercession." That is, Christ is neither capable of providing a bridge between individuals and God, nor does He need to. Muslims can go directly to God for their salvation, and receive forgiveness from their sins directly from that source by repenting. For that moment of salvation, Davies-Stofka explains, "At the end of time, all people will be rewarded or punished according to
how well they followed the instructions contained in God's revelations
to his prophets." Well, that kind of sounds familiar, like the idea of St. Peter standing at the pearly gates. She goes on, "Each person's deeds will be weighed in a balance, and if the evil deeds
outweigh the good deeds, the person will be condemned to the eternal
flame. If the good deeds outweigh the evil deeds, then the person will
be rewarded with paradise."
So basically, anyone, Muslim or not, can get into paradise simply by doing more good than evil. And evil can be erased through repentance, so that doing more good than evil would seem to be a fairly easy thing to do.
Bonus: They also teach that God is merciful. So... He might just show you mercy even if you've been a bastard.
So, what does it mean to do "good"? Well, here Boys reveals his ignorance and his prejudices about what is Good in Islam. He already believes Islam to require the conversion of the whole world, through violent means if necessary. Dying in the service of that conversion is the ultimate good.
This is also what I was taught.
Davies-Stofka claims, however, that good means something different: "A person's ultimate destiny, whether it is heaven or hell, depends on
the degree to which that person intended and acted as God desires, with
justice and mercy toward others."
On islamqa.com, a site intended for providing helpful support to Muslims from Muslims, they list 8 possible things you can do to be good, such as praying (3 different items on the list include prayer), reading the Qur'an, and "visiting the sick and giving charity." Notably absent on the list is "strapping a bomb to your chest and running into a crowded arena" or "attempting to convert others by lies and coercion."
So the "goals of Islam" include charitable works? Yeah, I'm OK with Muslims lying to advance those goals.
Boys then connects those two highly disparate dots by proclaiming that as a result of their lack of salvation and their pursuit of the expansion of Islam, lying means getting into Heaven. He's just made lying a "virtue" rather than a necessary evil.
Of course, then he goes completely off the deep end, proclaiming that the only sure way of entering Heaven is to die a martyr, and,
"Most Muslims will not have the 'opportunity' to become a martyr in this
war between Islam and the rest of the world and make no mistake every
true Muslim must be involved in making America (or the nation where he
lives) a Muslim nation. Since Muslims are limited in their ability to
die for the cause, they can help the cause by supporting terrorists with
money, succor, and cover."
Wow. Just wow. First of all, this assumes the moral imperative to make America a Muslim nation. I'm relatively certain the Qur'an never mention America, but hey, I've been wrong before.
But more importantly, it assumes that all Muslims believe that terrorists will be successful in their conversion of America by attacking it.
If Muslims really wanted to make America into a Muslim nation, the first thing they would do would be to blow up a small piece of it, because... uhm... you always attack countries when you want them to love you?
Where did Muslims in Boys' reality get their playbook? The Republican War Room?
Friday, September 26, 2014
Sunday, September 7, 2014
Love
Visiting another church this morning, and they sang a song that had the line, "and they'll know we are Christians by our love."
Is it love to assume the non-Christians who supposedly would recognize that are unloving or somehow unable to love as deeply as a Christian? Or, is it a proclamation that everyone who loves is a Christian, regardless of their professed religion?
Monday, September 1, 2014
The High Way, Part 1
Sometimes, when a Minneapolis highway meets up with another Minneapolis highway, the design is good - multiple lanes allow drivers to continue driving at high speeds, plenty of signage ahead of time allows drivers to prepare for their turns, and the lanes remain dedicated for a large distance, meaning that drivers can be back up to speed on the new highway and get comfortable in the flow of traffic there before having to merge.
That's good.
But then Minneapolis also has Tulsa-like highways. You see, we have only three highway interchanges through town that are reasonable. When I-244 meets up with 169, there are two dedicated lanes coming from the northbound 169 going to westbound I-244, and those two lanes remain in place all the way to highway 11. Similar things happen when I-244 meets 51 on the west side of downtown and where 169 meets the Creek Turnpike.
All the rest of Tulsa's highway interchanges are death traps.
One of the busiest interchanges in town is at highways 51 and 169. People coming from South Tulsa taking 169 attempt to turn to the northwest by getting on highway 51, and on the drive into work in the morning, this is the busiest flow of traffic. There are, however people having to come in from Broken Arrow and drive toward North Tulsa. The two flows of traffic cross each other - a giant volume of people slowing down to get on 51, a giant volume of people speeding up to get on 169, and using the same lane:
![]() |
| Image from Google Maps' Satellite Imagery |
Unfortunately, finding actual statistics on this interchange is difficult, but there is a plethora of information available about smart design in general. This type of interchange is known as a Cloverleaf Interchange. Here's a useful news article to help explain some of the problems and solutions.
So here's the deal - we know these problems exist, we know how to do better design, we know that cloverleaf interchanges typically take up *way more* land than alternatives. And yet, when we re-did this interchange only a few years ago... we re-did it simply by adding more lanes to the highways themselves and keeping the bloody dangerous interchanges exactly as they were.
Why do we do this? Well, my theory is that it has to do with money. We keep proving every bleeping day that money is more important in this city and state than the lives of any of its citizens. This derives directly from our conservative politics and its resultant "I've got mine" mentality: people who don't drive that interchange don't see a problem with it, partly because statistics are scarce and partly because those things that are out of sight are out of mind. But, even with campaigning to change this interchange, it won't be enough unless we can change that individualist mindset.
(More to come...)
Tuesday, August 26, 2014
Distant light Part 2 - Dinosaurs and Humans, living together
A responder on my Facebook page, after reading the first post about God's supposed lies, said,
"The Bible does mention dinosaurs."
Let's address that in detail.
First, the Bible makes several mentions to a "Leviathan." They are as follows (all verses from NIV):
Firstly, it has to be a sea creature. It moves quite well in the sea, according to Job, Isaiah, and whoever wrote that particular Psalm that described it as "frolic[king]." Historically, people have seen it in many different ways. In 1865, Gustave Doré saw it as a giant sea-snake:
In Liber Floridus, from the turn of the 12th century, Leviathan looked something like this (pictured with the anti-christ riding atop it):
And in William Blake's late-18th century depiction, it was the creature at the bottom:
None of which are very dinosaur-like. For the creature to be able to glide through the water as described in Isaiah, it needs to be relatively fish-like or serpent-like, as in these drawings. Since it has limbs, the closest to the Biblical description would be the middle drawing, which looks like a giant crocodile with a very long tail and wings. Wings, again, aren't mentioned anywhere in the description, so they're unnecessary, as are giant tusks and horns.
And of course, feathers aren't depicted in the Bible account.
You see, dinosaurs were feathered. Our depictions of them in movies and museums are totally inaccurate.
So it's patently impossible for the Leviathan to be describing a dinosaur. It mentions scales, and dinosaurs weren't scaled. It's amphibious, so the best thing we could go with is a prehistoric amphibian, like Mastodonsaurus.
But here's the next problem - let's just say that Mastodonsaurus is the leviathan of the Bible, and managing to live at the same time as Job - whence all the other dinosaurs?
We know that dinosaur tracks have been found in Israel, belonging to a dinosaur called Elaphrosaurus:
This thing was big. Head to tail, it would be 20 feet long. But besides the Leviathan, there is no record of any type of "dinosaur" or other giant creature in the Bible. Ergo - how come people running in terror from this beastie didn't record it in Scripture?
Lastly, let's have a little bit of a logical fleshing out of something that was said in the video: that the fossil record is out of whack because of the flood.
Let's be really clear about that.
Assuming they're entirely correct, which I disagree with but I'll accept for this one simple argument, then how is it that the fossil record after the flood... isn't?
You see, leviathan is mentioned, as I said, in Psalms, Isaiah, and Job. Psalms and Isaiah were clearly written after any such flood, as any reading of the Bible would tend to indicate. As the Answers In Genesis folks but the date of the flood as 4362 years ago, and the writer I quoted above had Job written 3,284 years ago, give or take a few years, Job was also likely written after any such theoretical flood.
Thus, everything that occurred after the flood should continue to follow normal geological processes, regardless of what happened before it. This means that there's no excuse for dinosaur fossils and human fossils to not be found right next to each other (especially when one of the creatures had us over for lunch, if you catch my meaning).
But we have lots and lots of dinosaur poop. There's never been the slightest trace of anything remotely resembling a human in it. We have lots and lots of dinosaur fossils and human fossils, but never from the same place. Layers of dirt would have been laid down at a steady rate after the flood, so those fossils buried in dirt would have no excuse not to be protected equally.
It just doesn't happen. That's because the idea of dinosaurs living at the same time as humans is preposterous.
Nope, not even Mastodonsaurus.
Try again.
"The Bible does mention dinosaurs."
Let's address that in detail.
First, the Bible makes several mentions to a "Leviathan." They are as follows (all verses from NIV):
- Job 3:8
May those who curse days curse that day those who are ready to rouse Leviathan.
(For context, Job 3:1 says, "After this, Job opened his mouth and cursed the day of his birth" and then provides his curses. Job 3:8 is one of his curses.) - Job 41 (all of it is a description of the Leviathan. It starts with this, in 41:1)
Can you pull in Leviathan with a fishhook
or tie down its tongue with a rope? - Psalm 74:14
It was you who crushed the heads of Leviathan
and gave it as food to the creatures of the desert. - Psalm 104:25-26
There is the sea, vast and spacious,
teeming with creatures beyond number—
living things both large and small.
There the ships go to and fro,
and Leviathan, which you formed to frolic there. - Isaiah 27:1 (Chapter titled: "Deliverance of Israel")In that day,the LORD will punish with his sword—
his fierce, great and powerful sword—
Leviathan the gliding serpent,
Leviathan the coiling serpent;
he will slay the monster of the sea.
- It is a creature of the sea, as denoted in Job 41:1 and 31-32, Psalm 104:26, and Isaiah 27:1.
- It "glides" and "coils" as per Isaiah 27:1.
- It has limbs as per Job 41:12.
- It has "strength and its graceful form" as per Job 41:12.
- It has a "double coat of armor" as per Job 41:13.
- Its mouth is "ringed about with fearsome teeth" as per Job 41:14.
- "Its back has rows of shields
tightly sealed together
each is so close to the next
that no air can pass between.
They are joined fast to one another;
they cling together and cannot be parted" (Job 41:15-17). - "Its snorting throws out flashes of light" (Job 41:18a).
- "Flames stream from its mouth;
sparks of fire shoot out." (Job 41:19). - "Smoke pours from its nostrils" (Job 41:20a).
- "Its breath sets coals ablaze,
and flames dart from its mouth" (Job 41:21). - "Strength resides in its neck" (Job 41:22a).
- "The folds of its flesh are tightly joined" (Job 41:23a).
- "Its chest is hard as rock," (Job 41:24a).
- It's impenetrable to all weapons at the very beginning of the iron age* (Job 41:25-29)
*if this exhaustive mathematical calculation is correct in assuming that it chronicles events from 1280-1270 B.C., then it would be taking place at the beginning of the iron age. - "Its undersides are jagged potsherds," (Job 41:30a).
- It leaves "a trail in the mud like a threshing sledge" (Job 41:30b).
A threshing sledge is a board covered with spikes or shards so that when dragged across cereal grains, it good remove the cereal from the straw. Note that I list this verse separately from the one above it because it's indicating that not only is this a creature that lives mostly in the sea, it also comes out of the sea, at least on muddy areas
Firstly, it has to be a sea creature. It moves quite well in the sea, according to Job, Isaiah, and whoever wrote that particular Psalm that described it as "frolic[king]." Historically, people have seen it in many different ways. In 1865, Gustave Doré saw it as a giant sea-snake:
| "Destruction of Leviathan". Gustave Doré, 1865 |
| By Lambert- Liber Floridus (1120) [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons |
And in William Blake's late-18th century depiction, it was the creature at the bottom:
| William Blake [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons |
None of which are very dinosaur-like. For the creature to be able to glide through the water as described in Isaiah, it needs to be relatively fish-like or serpent-like, as in these drawings. Since it has limbs, the closest to the Biblical description would be the middle drawing, which looks like a giant crocodile with a very long tail and wings. Wings, again, aren't mentioned anywhere in the description, so they're unnecessary, as are giant tusks and horns.
And of course, feathers aren't depicted in the Bible account.
You see, dinosaurs were feathered. Our depictions of them in movies and museums are totally inaccurate.
| Wired.com shows an artist's rendering of what the feathered T-Rex might have looked like |
But here's the next problem - let's just say that Mastodonsaurus is the leviathan of the Bible, and managing to live at the same time as Job - whence all the other dinosaurs?
We know that dinosaur tracks have been found in Israel, belonging to a dinosaur called Elaphrosaurus:
| By FunkMonk (Michael B. H.) (Own work) [CC-BY-SA-3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0) or GFDL (http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/fdl.html)], via Wikimedia Commons |
This thing was big. Head to tail, it would be 20 feet long. But besides the Leviathan, there is no record of any type of "dinosaur" or other giant creature in the Bible. Ergo - how come people running in terror from this beastie didn't record it in Scripture?
Lastly, let's have a little bit of a logical fleshing out of something that was said in the video: that the fossil record is out of whack because of the flood.
Let's be really clear about that.
Assuming they're entirely correct, which I disagree with but I'll accept for this one simple argument, then how is it that the fossil record after the flood... isn't?
You see, leviathan is mentioned, as I said, in Psalms, Isaiah, and Job. Psalms and Isaiah were clearly written after any such flood, as any reading of the Bible would tend to indicate. As the Answers In Genesis folks but the date of the flood as 4362 years ago, and the writer I quoted above had Job written 3,284 years ago, give or take a few years, Job was also likely written after any such theoretical flood.
Thus, everything that occurred after the flood should continue to follow normal geological processes, regardless of what happened before it. This means that there's no excuse for dinosaur fossils and human fossils to not be found right next to each other (especially when one of the creatures had us over for lunch, if you catch my meaning).
But we have lots and lots of dinosaur poop. There's never been the slightest trace of anything remotely resembling a human in it. We have lots and lots of dinosaur fossils and human fossils, but never from the same place. Layers of dirt would have been laid down at a steady rate after the flood, so those fossils buried in dirt would have no excuse not to be protected equally.
It just doesn't happen. That's because the idea of dinosaurs living at the same time as humans is preposterous.
Nope, not even Mastodonsaurus.
Try again.
Labels:
Absolute Truth,
Christian,
Christianity,
Dinosaurs,
Evolution
Nudism Interview
I interviewed recently for From a Basement in Tulsa. I talked briefly with him about the same kind of power issues I talk about here, so I thought I'd share here as well. I'm thinking about expounding upon them in my usual nature here, but in the mean time, check it out.
Distant light, dinosaur bones, and the fully-formed Earth
Why do we believe that the Bible is telling us the truth?
It's not because the Bible tells us it does - that'd be circular logic: the Bible is true because the Bible is true.
Rather, it's because we already believe the Bible is true that we're willing to accept what it says about itself. Why do we believe the Bible is true? Because we accept the idea that God is true and that the Bible is His message to us about how to be restored to life with Him.
What necessarily follows, then, is that we believe the Bible is true because we believe that A: God is real; B: God does not lie; and C: God wants us to know Him.
If that's true - and it's necessarily true for an inerrant Bible, for if we argue against those premises, we have to admit the possibility that the Bible is lying to us - then whence came dinosaurs?
I used to believe this: God, when He created the heavens and the Earth, also created the dinosaur bones and distant light to try to trip us up, to make us doubt Him and what He has said about Creation.
That argument is not consistent with a God who does not lie and desires us to know Him.
Because in that argument, God is the creator of two records - the Bible, and the physical reality (universe and planet). We can "read" both, if we are literate in the languages they were written in. One is true, the other is a lie - but both were written by God.
So isn't it true that accepting the science about the world is claiming that God is lying in the Bible?
No. Remember that the Bible never claims itself to be inerrant, only God-breathed. If we accept that it can be flawed - that is, that God did not write it Himself but through flawed intermediaries who took occasional shortcuts, then we can still accept that God is always truthful and that the Bible is His way of teaching us about certain aspects of Him - namely, His love and grace. If the Bible is, as my pastors told me so long ago, God's love-letter to humanity, why would we assume a love-letter is scientifically accurate? There's no point to. But it can still provide us insights about His love, if we're open to those insights.
There's also a way to read it, if you prefer, to say that the Bible is literally written word-for-word by God, and that, as with my love-letter argument above, God took shortcuts rather than attempting to explain everything to an ancient peoples who couldn't have possibly understood it. If God had told them that the world is billions of years old, they would've laughed at Him, because they couldn't read the world, couldn't understand the things they looked at, and sought answers for them in inappropriate places (such as other gods).
Thus, you can't argue that God created distant light or hid supposedly-ancient dinosaur bones and still argue that God loves us and wants us to know Him - but you can argue (and I threw that out there if you want to take it) that as ancient people were bad at reading the physical world, we are still. It's a fair argument, but good luck proving the science wrong. You'll have to engage science where it lives for that.
Labels:
Absolute Truth,
Christian,
Christianity,
Dinosaurs,
Evolution
Friday, August 22, 2014
Love, Morality, and Dawkins
I've talked a bit about the idea that love is the commandment that drives all others, and I'll certainly come back to that more later, but the comments by Richard Dawkins of late seem to necessitate a response.
From The Independent article on what he said,
But what about the second possibility, that they bring suffering and unhappiness to others? Fortunately for me, Jevan covered that topic, too:
Now, there are plenty of other arguments about birthing children that Dawkins wasn't making, and I'm not going to cover them here. It is, as he notes, up to the mom, and any mom who doesn't feel up to the task or doesn't feel she can provide the love and support a given child's needs must figure out for herself whether or not to have an abortion. For my own part, though, I think kids with Down Syndrome are awesome, even if I, too, suffer from societal judgmentalism regarding them (another prejudice I'm trying to work out of my mind).
From The Independent article on what he said,
“I honestly don't know what I would do if I were pregnant with a kid with Down Syndrome. Real ethical dilemma,” @InYourFaceNYer chimed in.Dawkins further fueled the fire with comments later:
“Abort it and try again. It would be immoral to bring it into the world if you have the choice,” he tweeted back
"If your morality is based, as mine is, on a desire to increase the sum of happiness and reduce suffering, the decision to deliberately give birth to a Down's baby, when you have the choice to abort it early in the pregnancy, might actually be immoral from the point of view of the child's own welfare." (Link)What he's saying here, then, is that he believes children with Down Syndrome are suffering and unhappy, or perhaps bring suffering and unhappiness to others (e.g. through increased financial and temporal costs for care). Amy Julia Becker wrote an account of her own experiences raising a child with Down Syndrome, noticing the same idea in society:
In other words, across the media landscape, children and adults who are going to work, interacting with their parents, experiencing the typical joys and sorrows of life, are nevertheless in a perpetual state of "suffering."The fact of the matter is that children who have Down Syndrome are happier than the rest of us. Jevan (last name unknown) from The Tribal Way wrote a blog on this topic that did an excellent job collating the research on Down Syndrome and happiness. He writes:
Findings from a study published in the American Journal of Medical Genetics surveyed 284 people with Down syndrome ..the results were as follows...
"The average age was 23, and 84 percent were living with one or both parents/guardians. The findings:
- 99 percent said they were happy with their lives
- 97 percent liked who they are
- 96 percent liked how they look
- 86 percent indicated they could make friends easily
- 4 percent expressed sadness about their life."
But what about the second possibility, that they bring suffering and unhappiness to others? Fortunately for me, Jevan covered that topic, too:
People with down syndrome are loved and cared for. Studies show that 79% of parents with those with down syndrome said their outlook on life had improved since having their child and that 94% of siblings of those with down children were proud of their DS brother or sister.So, by and large, having to "suffer" through raising a child with Down Syndrome is actually good for the parents and really good for their children who don't have Down Syndrome.
Now, there are plenty of other arguments about birthing children that Dawkins wasn't making, and I'm not going to cover them here. It is, as he notes, up to the mom, and any mom who doesn't feel up to the task or doesn't feel she can provide the love and support a given child's needs must figure out for herself whether or not to have an abortion. For my own part, though, I think kids with Down Syndrome are awesome, even if I, too, suffer from societal judgmentalism regarding them (another prejudice I'm trying to work out of my mind).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
